Lake Geneva's Premier Vacation Rental Management
Family-owned. Locally operated. Built on 13+ years of vacation rental experience.
Why Owners Choose Elite Lake Rentals
We're selective about the homes we manage—and what we deliver to the owners who trust us.
Family-Owned, Locally Operated
We personally manage every property and every relationship—you’re working directly with us, not an account manager. With over 13 years of vacation rental experience across Florida and Wisconsin, we know what it takes to deliver consistently for owners and guests.
Maximum Revenue, Dynamic Pricing
Our daily rate optimization adjusts pricing based on supply, demand, and local events—not a static rate card. Transparent strategy, no hidden fees, full revenue accountability.
Premium Guest Screening + Damage Protection
No security deposit hassle for guests, full protection for owners. Every reservation includes $1M general liability, $1M bodily injury, and $10,000 in contents coverage per guest stay.
Smart Home Tech + 24/7 Monitoring
Brivo smart home system with cellular backup and Yale keyless locks, unique guest codes that auto-activate at check-in and deactivate at check-out, and Minut noise sensors that allow proactive management of when guests get noisy before it becomes an issue, year-round temperature monitoring, and smoke and alarm detection.
Hotel-Grade Housekeeping + Inspections
Pre-arrival inspections with a local welcome gift. Post-departure inspections after every stay. Off-site professional laundry. Deep cleans after summer season. Your property stays in showroom condition.
Trust Accounting + Transparent Payouts
Owner payments via ACH on the 10th of each month for the prior month’s departures. Strict trust accounting. Full ledger access. Zero hidden fees—because this is a partnership.
“Elite has been managing our rental property since 2023. We were new to the STR world and they honestly made it so easy. They are extremely dependable and professional. All of the reviews on our property speak of how the host was quick to respond and easy to work with. We feel very lucky to have found both Heather and Jason. 5 stars, highly recommend if you are looking for a management company.”
— Natalia H., Property Owner
Visit Us
Local Presence. Real Office. Real People.
Elite Lake Rentals
Landmark Center Building
772 W Main St, Suite 202
Lake Geneva, WI 53147
Business Hours
9:30 AM – 9:00 PM CST, daily
Available 24/7 for emergencies
How It Works
From inquiry to first booking in under 30 days.
Free Rental Projection
Tell us about your home. We’ll analyze the market and provide a transparent revenue projection.
Onboarding & Photography
We coordinate professional photography, smart home installation, and listing setup.
Smart Home Setup & Launch
Brivo locks, Minut sensors, and your listing goes live across all major platforms.
First Booking → Ongoing Management
Dynamic pricing, guest screening, housekeeping, inspections, owner payments. We handle everything.
Free Rental Projection
Tell us about your home. We’ll analyze the market and provide a transparent revenue projection.
Onboarding & Photography
We coordinate professional photography, smart home installation, and listing setup.
Smart Home Setup & Launch
Brivo locks, Minut sensors, and your listing goes live across all major platforms.
First Booking → Ongoing Management
Dynamic pricing, guest screening, housekeeping, inspections, owner payments. We handle everything.
What Sets Us Apart
| Elite Lake Rentals | Other Managers |
|---|---|
| Boutique portfolio (20 hand-selected homes) | High-volume, accept-anyone approach |
| Direct access to owners (Jason & Heather) | Account managers and call centers |
| Daily dynamic pricing with full transparency | Static rates or opaque pricing strategies |
| $1M general liability + $1M bodily injury + $10K contents per stay | Variable damage protection, often gaps |
| Off-site professional laundry, deep cleans, post-storm inspections | Standard housekeeping only |
| Owner payments on the 10th, every month | Variable or delayed payouts |
| 100% transparent fees | Hidden fees, unclear deductions |
| 4.9★ across 400+ guest reviews | — |
Frequently Asked Questions
Detailed answers to the questions owners ask most.
About Elite Lake Rentals
Property Management Operations
Housekeeping & Inspections
Damage Protection & Guest Screening
Smart Home & Security
Noise & Privacy Monitoring
Rates & Revenue
Ready to Talk?
Get a free rental projection. We'll analyze your property and the market, then walk you through what's possible.
Or call us directly: 262-254-6688
Email: jason@elitelakerentals.com
We respond within 24 hours, every time.
Visit our office: 772 W Main St, Suite 202, Lake Geneva, WI 53147
When you work with Elite Lake Rentals, you're working directly with us — Jason and Heather.
